Emmerdale shocked us all by revealing a body in the lake was Nate and while everyone has a theory, could Tracy have been the one to put him there?

When Nate exited the show last year, eagle-eyed fans immediately knew something was suspect about his departure. And for months there have been countless theories suggesting he was d3ad, but nobody actually fully believed it. And in a huge twist during the limo lake crash – his body was under the lake. 

Now that viewers are aware of this, they are watching the soap more carefully than ever, waiting for something to give a clue to who the k!ller is. And while it may seem out of the blue, could it have been Tracy? Here are the latest odds on who put Nate in the lake.
Could Tracy have k!lled Nate? (Credit: ITV)

Emmerdale: Did Tracy k!ll Nate?

As soon as it was confirmed to be Nate’s body, the theory that John Sugden is actually a serial k!ller looked extremely plausible. But odds suggest this may actually not be the case. And some people in the line-up are quite surprising.

According to Gambling.com expert James Leyfield, Tracy, who supposedly loved Nate, has made it to the list of suspects. And admitted the soap could pull a “double bluff”.

Her and Nate had their ups and downs (and affairs), but ultimately they did love each other. However, in the end it wasn’t enough. And as Nate decided to give up his time in the village, Tracy and him split for good.

She made a comment to John about how Nate didn’t even say goodbye. But perhaps she was actually the one who k!lled him and is covering her tracks. And with the birthday present for Frankie plot-hole, she would be the perfect candidate.

While she is on the list, she’s currently at the bottom, with 25/1 (3.8%) likelihood of being the m-u-rderer.
Nate was confirmed d3ad during the limo stunt (Credit: ITV)

Who are the main suspects for Nate’s m-u-rder?

Shockingly, John is not the current favourite to be the m-u–rderer. The number one spot actually goes to Caleb – Nate’s uncle.

Caleb is sitting at the top with a 6/4 (40%) chance of being responsible. But what makes viewers so convinced?

After the m-u-rder was revealed, Caleb was putting on a black hoodie leaving his house. Then not long after that, a hooded figure was standing at the lake. 

And he cared about Tracy, so if he knew about her and Nate’s argument or if Nate accused him of starting up his affair with his wife again, could things have gotten out of control?

Right behind Caleb, however, is suspicious John Sugden (if that’s really his name). He sits with a 2/1 (33.3%) likelihood of being the one who k!lled Nate.

Ever since he first arrived fans have been adamant that he is hiding something sinister. And many assume he is a m-u-rderer. With him supposedly being the last one to see Nate alive, did he deliver the final blow?