Simon Cowell reveals Amanda Holden was his second choice for BGT panel after huge star ‘freaked out’ and quit ‘a week before filming’
The panel could’ve looked pretty different…
BGT boss Simon Cowell has admitted Amanda Holden – part of the ITV show’s judging panel since 2007 – wasn’t his first pick for the role.
The pair are currently joined by Alesha Dixon and Bruno Tonioli for the judging line up for the 18th series, with influencer KSI also making guest appearances.
But back when the telly talent hunt first started airing nearly two decades ago, it was former newspaper editor Piers Morgan who popped up on screen alongside Amanda and Simon.
However, if Simon had had his way, Amanda might not have had the opportunity to make the Saturday night primetime spot her own.

When BGT first aired on the box, the judges included Piers Morgan, Amanda Holden, and Simon Cowell (Credit: YouTube)
BGT boss Simon Cowell nearly didn’t employ Amanda Holden
That’s because, according to reports, then-Girls Aloud star Cheryl was wanted for the judging job.
Simon is reported to have claimed the Fight for This Love singer changed her mind about being part of BGT just days before filming was scheduled to begin.
Simon is quoted as saying he reckons Chezza may have been “freaked out”.
Praising Amanda, Simon said: “She is our Britain’s Got Talent queen and she deserves that crown.”
He then went on to recall how the series could have been very different if the original casting had transpired and Amanda hadn’t been added to the mix.

Cheryl and Simon Cowell later appeared on screen together on The X Factor (Credit: YouTube)
‘We’d offered the role to Cheryl Cole’
Simon reflected: “And you know what? [Amanda] was an interesting booking because we’d offered the role to Cheryl Cole, as she was known in those days.
“A week before filming, she calls me and goes: ‘I just can’t do it,’ and wouldn’t give me a reason. I think she was freaked out. We literally had two judges and a week to book someone.”
Simon added: “I just knew it had to be Amanda because I’d met her and I really liked her. She was very funny and I just thought she’d fit the show perfectly. Fast forward 18 years and she’s still a huge success and we have become great friends. I do consider her one of my best friends.”

Amanda Holden has been the queen of BGT for nearly two decades (Credit: YouTube)
Instead, Cheryl went on to be a mainstay on the panel for The X Factor from 2008 for three years. She then went on to appear briefly in the US version of the singing series. During her first run Cheryl mentored Alexandra Burke and Joe McElderry to series wins.
She later returned to the UK show for two seasons from 2014 after her three-week stint on the US series.
News
I Was a Pregnant Janitor Hiding in a Billionaire’s Mansion, Certain He Only Wanted My Baby — But I Had No Idea Damien Blaze Had Already Chosen Me, and the Family That Tried to destroy me was about to learn how dangerous love makes a powerful man
I Was a Pregnant Janitor Hiding in a Billionaire’s Mansion, Certain He Only Wanted My Baby — But I Had No Idea Damien Blaze Had Already Chosen Me, and the Family That Tried to destroy me was about to learn…
My Son Begged Me for Days to Believe Something Was Crawling Inside His Cast — But I Had No Idea the Woman I Married Had Hidden a nightmare under the bandages, and by the time the truth burst open, I had already betrayed the child who trusted me most
My Son Begged Me for Days to Believe Something Was Crawling Inside His Cast — But I Had No Idea the Woman I Married Had Hidden a nightmare under the bandages, and by the time the truth burst open, I…
They Left My Little Girl Alone in a Locked Car During a Heatwave, Then Expected Me to Lie to Protect the Family — But They Didn’t Know the Woman They’d Trained to absorb everything was about to choose her daughter over their comfort for the first time in her life
They Left My Little Girl Alone in a Locked Car During a Heatwave, Then Expected Me to Lie to Protect the Family — But They Didn’t Know the Woman They’d Trained to absorb everything was about to choose her daughter…
My Stepsister Slapped Me in Front of Five Hundred Wedding Guests and Said I Didn’t Belong There — But She Had No Idea the Woman She Humiliated Was the Owner of Vance Global Holdings, and Within Minutes Her Groom Called Off the Wedding
My Stepsister Slapped Me in Front of Five Hundred Wedding Guests and Said I Didn’t Belong There — But She Had No Idea the Woman She Humiliated Was the Owner of Vance Global Holdings, and Within Minutes Her Groom Called…
My Ex-Husband’s Mother Dumped a Bucket of Filthy Ice Water Over My Pregnant Body at Dinner — But They Had No Idea the Woman They Mocked Was the Hidden Founder of the Empire Keeping Their Entire Family Rich, and Ten Minutes Later He Was Begging on His Knees.
She kept laughing while the water ran down my face. He laughed with her. That was the moment they lost everything. The bucket hit me so fast I didn’t even have time to flinch. One second I was sitting at…
My Husband Thought Divorce Court Would End With Me Broke, Humiliated, and Completely Alone — But He Didn’t Know the Mother I Hadn’t Seen in Nineteen Years Was About to Walk In Wearing White, Expose His hidden millions, and Tear His Whole Life Apart.
He thought I would walk in alone. He thought hunger had made me weak. He had no idea who was about to open that courtroom door. Keith Simmons was already smiling before the judge even sat down. Not a nervous…
End of content
No more pages to load