SH0CK – Carson Daly’s Past EXPOSED live on Today, leaves viewers Stunned!

Carson Daly’s Today co-hosts aren’t going to let him live down his romantic past.

One late ‘90s relationship came up on Tuesday, July 15, during Daly’s Pop Start segment on Today. As he was discussing the I Know What You Did Last Summer franchise, which stars Daly’s ex-girlfriend, Jennifer Love Hewitt, Daly’s co-hosts couldn’t help but tease him.

When Daly showed a photo of costars Sarah Michelle Gellar and Freddie Prinze Jr. posing together on the red carpet in 2025 and the original red carpet in 1997, Savannah Guthrie quickly chimed in.

“Were you at that premiere?” Guthrie asked, while Jenna Bush Hager repeated the question, asking, “ Did you go to that premiere?”

Daly played it coy, replying, “I’m not sure. I can’t remember 30 years ago.”

But Guthrie was quick to declare, “We know what you did that summer.”

Daly laughed off the comments, saying, “Yeah, I’ve heard the jokes. I’m aware.”

Guthrie urged viewers to “Google it” as Daly called his co-hosts a “tough crowd.”

Daly and Love Hewitt dated for about a year in the late ’90s. And while he didn’t attend the original 1997 premiere, Daly was by his ex’s side for the premiere of 1998’s I Still Know What You Did Last Summer.

During Tuesday’s broadcast, Daly didn’t mention Hewitt’s appearance at the I Know What You Did Last Summer premiere alongside Prinze Jr. and Gellar.

This isn’t the first time Guthrie and Bush Hager have teased Daly about his celebrity dating past. In May, the pair poked fun at Daly while discussing the viral TikTok prank “I’m so hungry, I could eat…” — a game in which the participant then names a person their fellow player may find uncomfortable discussing.

“I’m so hungry I could eat a Jennifer Love Hewitt,” Bush Hager teased at the time.

Daly has been married to Siri Pinter since 2015. The couple shares son Jackson and daughters Etta, London and Goldie.

He’s been on amicable terms with Love Hewitt for years after the actress appeared on his talk show Last Call with Carson Daly in 2005. At the time, he showed his ex the tattoo coverup he did to hide her name, which he had inked on his ankle.

He jokingly asked Love Hewitt if it was hard for her to not have a steady boyfriend after their split.

“You know, it has been difficult to recover,” she quipped at the time.

Daly added that their romance “ended a little weird,” and Love Hewitt agreed, adding, “It did, but that doesn’t matter.”